Ended up going with youi, at ~$103 a month with $600 excess and first 2 years new car replacement with owner preferred repairer, which I thought was a pretty good deal compared to some of the others.
On a side note, their house insurance was dearer than CommInsure.
I just purchased a 2009 Passat CC v6 and insured it today. I'm in 35yo in Sydney Eastern Suburbs and have a full no claim bonus, and chose c. $800 excess. Here's the comparison of quotes I found:
Coles - $1200
Woolies - $1380
Bingle - $1060
Progressive - $1140
AAMI - $1150
GE - $1310
Budget Direct - $920
Allianz - $1360
NRMA - $1045
Shannons - $2600 (wouldn't honour NCD without current insurance)
Youi - $2600 (wouldn't honour NCD without current insurance)
I took NRMA as they have a strong reputation, and gave me a market value of $35,700.
Hope this is helpful
Bookmarks