Look at the compressor maps.
At pressure ratio of about 1.6, the garrett is going to be out of its efficient range at a nominal "coming on throttle at mid rpm's" type flow number of 0.07kg/s. The K03 is in its efficent place for the same flow and pressure ratio.
I would say that at low-mid rpm, the big turbo will work fine but it will be slower than with the k03. at high rpm, when the garrett unit becomes more efficient, you will see the reverse effect (which is bad for any given tune, because you will "lean out".
Turbo compressor maps are not the enemy. People (all people on car forums who are into turbo's) should really take the time to understand how to read them and use them in order to make decisions about turbocharging. There's great satisfaction in understanding the physics, doing the calucations and having your results verified inthe real world, as I have done personally. Much nicer than learning through doubtful heresay on forums (not that anyone said anything really wrong, its just that its better to know why, than just to know.)
'07 Touareg V6 TDI with air suspension
'98 Mk3 Cabriolet 2.0 8V
'99 A4 Quattro 1.8T
Bookmarks