Support VWWC

Page 25 of 36 FirstFirst ... 15232425262735 ... LastLast
Results 241 to 250 of 354

Thread: Skoda RS replacement tyres - interesting

  1. #241
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Sydney
    Posts
    1,605

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    The odd thing about it all is that I can't find any Skoda reference to vRS tyre speed ratings. I thought it was law to have it on the vehicle tyre placard, which is inside the fuel cap flap, but it's not there, only the tyre sizes relevant to engine power output in kW.
    Hmm, not particularly helpful.

    Skoda has a list of approved tyre sizes and fitments (with the corresponding load index and speed symbol) for each of its vehicles in the workshop manual. One would need access to ElsaWin or ask your nearest friendly dealer to print out the list.

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    It gives the production date, and some weights, which I think may be relevant to tyre load indexes of axle group 1 (front tyres), and axle group 2 (rear tyres), but it doesn't say so.
    The maximum axle load is but one of many factors that engineers consider when specifying a tyre during the car's design phase.

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    The point of all this is that NSW law doesn't say that you must fit the same speed rating as originally fitted by a manufacturer.
    Yes, to the best of my knowledge, that regulation still stands.

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    I'm not going to be doing anywhere near 300 kph in my RS oil burner wagon, but there are possible insurance issues at stake. There have been quite a few references to RSs having "Y' speed rated tyres, because that's what they arrive with, but has anyone got it in black and white as to what the manufacturers speed rating spec actually is? I'm buggered if I can find one.
    Although a tyre's speed symbol is an indication of it's maximum operating speed, it also reflects it's construction and resistance to heat, which has implications on its ability to cope with dynamic loads and forces over time.

    Try not to focus too much on the 'headline figure' of 300 km/h.

    Having said that, it is uncommon for most 225/40 R18 summer tyres to have a speed symbol of V (240 km/h) or less. Most summer tyres in that size tend to be W-rated (270 km/h) or Y-rated (300 km/h).

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    Sorry for the crap photography, but note the differences between dodgey's placard compared to the one on my MY11. No load index, and no minimum speed rating.
    The load index of a tyre is not arbitrarily assigned to a tyre size.
    Every tyre size has a corresponding load index as specified by the ETRTO (European Tyre and Rim Technical Organisation):

    A 225/45 R17 will have a load index of 91 (standard load) or 94 (extra load).

    A 225/40 R18 will have a load index of 88 (standard load) or 92 (extra load).


    Though there would be less confusion if the placard included the respective load index for each tyre.

    You may see some slight variations in the load index depending on which standard the tyre was manufactured to (ETRTO = Europe, TRA = USA, JATMA = Japan are the three major associations) but this is uncommon for passenger car tyres sold in Australia, so you are unlikely to encounter this.

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    I'm assuming so. That and that the first two weights are the unladed and laden, or gross and tare weights, and the next two, shown as 1 and 2 are the axle group weights. "1" is always the front, and "2" is always the rear.

    Five weights, five assumptions. What's the point of a bunch of numbers on an "information" plate without any indication of what they're relevant to?
    1985 kg: Gross vehicle mass (GVM)
    3385 kg: Gross combination mass (GCM) i.e. permissible gross mass with trailer
    1060 kg: Maximum permissible front axle load
    950 kg: Maximum permissible rear axle load
    650 kg: Permissible unbraked trailer load

    This information should be in the owner's manual.

    ...

    Given the odds, fitting tyres with a lesser speed symbol than the original tyres (within reason) won't have a noticeably adverse affect on safety - particularly if you drive in a conservative manner.

  2. #242
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Erskineville, NSW
    Posts
    7,591
    Users Country Flag
    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post


    Mine is the same format as dodgey's with a load index of 91 but a min speed rating of V (because I have the 1.8tsi).

    I'd almost suggest that you have the wrong decal under the fuel flap. It wouldn't be the first time this has happened on a VW group vehicle - some of the Transporters had similar issues.
    carandimage The place where Off-Topic is On-Topic
    I used to think I was anal-retentive until I started getting involved in car forums

  3. #243
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Earlwood, NSW
    Posts
    292
    Quote Originally Posted by Diesel_vert View Post
    Skoda has a list of approved tyre sizes and fitments (with the corresponding load index and speed symbol) for each of its vehicles in the workshop manual. One would need access to ElsaWin or ask your nearest friendly dealer to print out the list.
    Yes, I was going to ask the Service Dept of the dealership where I'll be getting my 30K service done.


    The maximum axle load is but one of many factors that engineers consider when specifying a tyre during the car's design phase.
    For sure. It's no so relevant to the average car driver, but ask any trucky who's ever been booked for being overweight not on the gross vehicle mass, but on one specific axle.

    Yes, to the best of my knowledge, that regulation still stands.
    Confusing though as it clearly says, "strongly recommended" rather than must, but then says if you do reduce the speed rating from that shown on the "vehicle's tyre placard" you "must" put a sticker on the windscreen. My point is I don't have a speed rating on my vehicle tyre placard. How does that comply with ADR's?

    Although a tyre's speed symbol is an indication of it's maximum operating speed, it also reflects it's construction and resistance to heat, which has implications on its ability to cope with dynamic loads and forces over time.

    Try not to focus too much on the 'headline figure' of 300 km/h.

    Having said that, it is uncommon for most 225/40 R18 summer tyres to have a speed symbol of V (240 km/h) or less. Most summer tyres in that size tend to be W-rated (270 km/h) or Y-rated (300 km/h).
    Yep! Understand that as well. Some tyres are even dual/multi rated, some cars are dual/multi placarded, and a speed rating of ZR is for 240 kph+, so it incorporates both W, and Y.



    The load index of a tyre is not arbitrarily assigned to a tyre size.
    Every tyre size has a corresponding load index as specified by the ETRTO (European Tyre and Rim Technical Organisation):

    A 225/45 R17 will have a load index of 91 (standard load) or 94 (extra load).

    A 225/40 R18 will have a load index of 88 (standard load) or 92 (extra load).


    Though there would be less confusion if the placard included the respective load index for each tyre.
    I'm on top of that too, but as you've said, a vehicle's tyre placard should indicate a minimum LI for each of the specified sizes on it.


    1985 kg: Gross vehicle mass (GVM)
    3385 kg: Gross combination mass (GCM) i.e. permissible gross mass with trailer
    1060 kg: Maximum permissible front axle load
    950 kg: Maximum permissible rear axle load
    650 kg: Permissible unbraked trailer load

    This information should be in the owner's manual.
    On page 261 of my book the weights for 125kW TDI shows the Combi RS DQ6 "Permissable gross weight" to be 1985 kg, and the "Permissable trailer loads, trailer unbraked" to be 650 kg. The other weights shown in the book do not correlate to any of the other weights on the plate on my car.

    Given the odds, fitting tyres with a lesser speed symbol than the original tyres (within reason) won't have a noticeably adverse affect on safety - particularly if you drive in a conservative manner.
    Mate, I agree with everything you've said, including this bit. I'm more concerned about whether an over zealous insurance assessor will see it the same way though.

  4. #244
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Earlwood, NSW
    Posts
    292
    Quote Originally Posted by dArK5HaD0w View Post
    i've got an my11, but i have the same placard as dodgey's.
    but mine is a petrol, not a diesel like urs.
    Weird. I know it's a rubbish photo, but if you strain your eyes a bit you can see that my placard shows sizes for both the 125kW diesel, and the 147kW petrol, in both 17" and 18" sizes.
    Last edited by BottomScratcher; 01-11-2012 at 02:54 PM.

  5. #245
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Earlwood, NSW
    Posts
    292
    Quote Originally Posted by brad View Post
    I'd almost suggest that you have the wrong decal under the fuel flap. It wouldn't be the first time this has happened on a VW group vehicle - some of the Transporters had similar issues.
    Mate, right or wrong, it's as useful as a Polly Waffle in a knife fight. I'll check with the dealer when I get time and post an update after I do.

  6. #246
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Sydney
    Posts
    1,605
    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    My point is I don't have a speed rating on my vehicle tyre placard. How does that comply with ADR's?
    It doesn't.

    So I wonder - does that mean the authorities can technically declare your vehicle as being unroadworthy, unregisterable, and thus render your comprehensive and third-party insurance null and void?

    Or am I being overly dramatic?


    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    On page 261 of my book the weights for 125kW TDI shows the Combi RS DQ6 "Permissable gross weight" to be 1985 kg, and the "Permissable trailer loads, trailer unbraked" to be 650 kg. The other weights shown in the book do not correlate to any of the other weights on the plate on my car.
    I'd be inclined to think that misprints are common in owner's manuals, but rarer on a vehicle's EC type-approval plate.

    But in case of discrepancies, I suppose it would be safest to assume the correct figures are the lower of the two.


    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    I'm more concerned about whether an over zealous insurance assessor will see it the same way though.
    I don't think it matters what their view is - the regulations in NSW are pretty clear IMO.

  7. #247
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Earlwood, NSW
    Posts
    292
    Quote Originally Posted by Diesel_vert View Post
    It doesn't.

    So I wonder - does that mean the authorities can technically declare your vehicle as being unroadworthy, unregisterable, and thus render your comprehensive and third-party insurance null and void?

    Or am I being overly dramatic?
    No, it doesn't.

    There's a not so good picture of my tyre placard above, and there's no speed ratings or LI's stated on it anywhere. Only tyre sizes and pressures are listed. That's why I questioned, as you have done, as to how it can comply with ADR's let alone state authorities, and also mentioned over zealous insurance assessors. Whether overdramatic, or not, it wouldn't even be a consideration if the bloody info was on the so-called tyre placard where it's supposed to be.

    Quote Originally Posted by Diesel_vert View Post
    I'd be inclined to think that misprints are common in owner's manuals, but rarer on a vehicle's EC type-approval plate.

    But in case of discrepancies, I suppose it would be safest to assume the correct figures are the lower of the two.
    Agreed. Another reason to state what the weights represent rather than just list them. What the Owners Manual calls the "Tyre Plate" (also a pic in a previous post) bears no tyre info at all. It shows a list of weights with no reference to what they represent.

    Quote Originally Posted by Diesel_vert View Post
    I don't think it matters what their view is - the regulations in NSW are pretty clear IMO.
    Which brings us back to square one, because the regulation specifically refers to the speed rating on the vehicle tyre placard, and mine doesn't show any speed rating/s.

    It's bizarre that I need to ask a dealer for info necessary to ensure that when I replace the car's tyres I'm complying with the manufacturers specs, state legislation, and subsequently insurers terms and conditions applicable to my policy.

  8. #248
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Canberra, ACT
    Posts
    2,260
    Users Country Flag
    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    Weird. I know it's a rubbish photo, but if you strain your eyes a bit you can see that my placard shows sizes for both the 125kW diesel, and the 147kW petrol, in both 17" and 18" sizes.
    in some countries, like ireland & china, the vrs comes with 17" as standard, not 18".
    MY17 Superb 162TSI, Business Grey, Tech+Comfort Pack, APR ECU+TCU Stg 1, SLA, Rieger Splitter + Side Skirts, Eibach Pro-Kit Springs, Hardrace Swaybar, TPMS

  9. #249
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Earlwood, NSW
    Posts
    292
    Quote Originally Posted by dArK5HaD0w View Post
    in some countries, like ireland & china, the vrs comes with 17" as standard, not 18".
    On my placard the 17s are a 45 profile, and the 18s are a 40 profile, but not a speed rating, or load index for any of them.

  10. #250
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Sydney
    Posts
    1,605

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    There's a not so good picture of my tyre placard above, and there's no speed ratings or LI's stated on it anywhere. Only tyre sizes and pressures are listed. That's why I questioned, as you have done, as to how it can comply with ADR's let alone state authorities, and also mentioned over zealous insurance assessors. Whether overdramatic, or not, it wouldn't even be a consideration if the bloody info was on the so-called tyre placard where it's supposed to be.
    I wasn't being that serious and, despite your concerns, I simply don't foresee it being an issue.

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    Agreed. Another reason to state what the weights represent rather than just list them. What the Owners Manual calls the "Tyre Plate" (also a pic in a previous post) bears no tyre info at all. It shows a list of weights with no reference to what they represent.
    What you're referring to is called the EC type-approval plate, which is required for every car sold in the EU, and the information on it is standardised (which is how I knew what they meant).

    It's not a tyre plate - if the owner's manual refers to it as such, it's a misprint or a typo.

    Quote Originally Posted by BottomScratcher View Post
    Which brings us back to square one, because the regulation specifically refers to the speed rating on the vehicle tyre placard, and mine doesn't show any speed rating/s.

    It's bizarre that I need to ask a dealer for info necessary to ensure that when I replace the car's tyres I'm complying with the manufacturers specs, state legislation, and subsequently insurers terms and conditions applicable to my policy.
    If we can ignore the placard shenanigans and just be practical for a moment, it would be safe to assume that the manufacturer approved fitments for the Octavia RS are:

    225/45 R17 91W
    225/40 R18 92Y XL

    You can verify this after you've obtained the print out from the workshop manual.

    And yes, you shouldn't have to ask the dealer (though it isn't a big inconvenience in the grand scheme of things), but such is life.

Page 25 of 36 FirstFirst ... 15232425262735 ... LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
| |