I am a fan of italian cars in general but after a series of fiats and alfas (with Peugots and BMWs in between) I can honestly say my experience with the Polo has been the best by far. Mine is just over 3 years old and not once have I ever got into the car wondering what is going to break today. Just jump on the owners forums and you will get a feel for the difference. Plus it handles better, rides better and is faster. The Punto does look good, but once you are inside things start to feel a little fragile....

That said, strech a couple of $k's and you may just get yourself into a Ritmo.