There is only one advantage of a welded diff and that's cost. I have tried pretty much all types of diffs in 30+ years of racing FWD cars and the 1.5 way multiplate diff is my go to choice. Properly set up they provide more than sufficient locking on power application whilst also allowing some differential action on turn in whilst giving some limitations on inside wheel lock up under braking. The biggest problem I found with welded diffs in FWD cars is the sudden change of direction, when say someone has a lose in front of you, if you back off, brake and steer at the same time they will almost instantly spin, nonrecoverably. With a plate diff, it will unlock on back off and give you some chance of recovery, steering to avoid the accident or the armco.
Torson (ramp locking) style diffs are all just too slow, they allow too much wheelspin before locking.
We still run solid centre diffs (spools) in a lot of RWD cars, but I'm constantly tuning them to avoid the turn in understeer whilst not invoking even more corner exit oversteer. They work but it's hard work setting up the car around them. I'd much rather have a plate diff every time, makes my job easier. Yes, they cost more initially and have to be serviced, but easily worth the extra.
Cheers
Gary
Bookmarks