Which Insurance company are you with?

[richmurphy]

I wouldn't say I'm giving GIO the nod. They suited me based on their reputation. AAMI have their place too and I have say their customer service is the best I've seen. You just need to be aware of what is covered in the policy (or exclusions are probably more relevant) and how repairs are carried out (basically the job is awarded to the lowest bidder). They were perfect for my 7 year old Mazda which was only worth $10k.

Also realise that excess can be over $1000 for a GTI and that goes a reasonable way towards repairing panel damage. It's not so much the minor damage that worries me - it's anything between minor and complete write off.

[Dutch77]

I wouldn't say I'm giving GIO the nod. They suited me based on their reputation. AAMI have their place too and I have say their customer service is the best I've seen. You just need to be aware of what is covered in the policy (or exclusions are probably more relevant) and how repairs are carried out (basically the job is awarded to the lowest bidder). They were perfect for my 7 year old Mazda which was only worth $10k.

Also realise that excess can be over $1000 for a GTI and that goes a reasonable way towards repairing panel damage. It's not so much the minor damage that worries me - it's anything between minor and complete write off.

I'll only use insurance with choice of repairer for my car, but agree for something on the cheaper end it probably doesn't matter so much.

That's where Allianz were good for me up until any mod is done - cheap premium, choice of repairer, minimal excess and agreed value about $10k more than anyone else is offering.

[crackdawg]

there are some good deals in here which really surprises me... ive got a MKVI 103TDI 30yrs old garaged in inner melb eastern suburb, never had an accident/suspension and last fine was 2005 and the premium is $1100/year - i tried racv, suncorp, justcars, allianz, colesinsurance and aami were the cheapest by far.

then some of you have GTI/R's under 25 for similar money.... very odd

[richmurphy]

there are some good deals in here which really surprises me... ive got a MKVI 103TDI 30yrs old garaged in inner melb eastern suburb, never had an accident/suspension and last fine was 2005 and the premium is $1100/year - i tried racv, suncorp, justcars, allianz, colesinsurance and aami were the cheapest by far.

then some of you have GTI/R's under 25 for similar money.... very odd

I found the same. Maybe it's just a Melbourne thing? Actually I found my wife's Accord Euro was more expensive than the GTI and it only has agreed value of $25k!

[Dutch77]

I remember Motor magazine used to have a monthly page/column along the lines of 'how much does it really cost' and would feature a car each month with the estimated annual running costs over three years.. and they always used to quote premiums for Mr Average (I think 'he' was a 35 yo with clean record) in Melbourne and Sydney that were about 3 times what I'd expect to pay here in Adelaide. Now I doubt they spent much time researching this, but the point is location does a play a big part in the premium calculation a lot of the time.

[gtimike]

I was suprised of some of the prices when i went shopping for insurance,im 28 and have no crash history,i ended up with NRMA and am paying 1200 a year on a golf MK6 GTI.

[Dutch77]

Now I doubt they spent much time researching this, but the point is location does a play a big part in the premium calculation a lot of the time.

Thought I'd check it out for myself.. a quote in my current spot vs if I moved to Melbourne (eg St Kilda) or Sydney (eg Wollstonecraft). Melbourne +51% increased in premium; Sydney +54%.

Obviously there are other factors - some likely to be far more important - but interesting to see this all the same.

[Lemonskin]

Well I have a Polo GTI not a Golf but my comprehensive insurance with NRMA was $650/year with premium of $650 too.

Car garaged outside of Sydney Metro area though so that really helped bring the cost down.

[thrupence]

22 in a 2012 Golf R, cheapest I could find was $1980 a year with NRMA - 5 year perfect driving record and 65% no claim bonus. Some quotes came in around 10k!

[Dutch77]

Tried quick quotes with Shannon's and Justcar to get a guide.. Shannon's were hopeless, stupid premium for low agreed value

Seems like I was being unfair with quick-quoting with Shannons - a more detailed on the phone quote sees them still 25% more expensive than RAA on premium; but more freedom with modifications and a higher agreed value.

Plus the dude knew who Viezu was.