If you had to spend your cash (let's say the figure is about $45K for the sake of this thread) on something else what would it be and why. New and Used.

New

For me, it has to be the Alfa Romeo Giulietta (with the 125Kw 1.4L multi-air).

Gorgeous to look at, apparently quite well made and exciting to drive. Finally an Alfa that you can buy with the head and the heart.

The only other car that tickles my fancy is the current MX-5 - but I owned one of those in 2006 (it is glorious, almost perfect) so I'd opt for the new Alfa.

Used

E46 BMW 330Ci. The 3 series before they stuffed them up with run flats, iDrive and forgettable styling. You'd buy it for the noise of the straight six alone.

Offer this guy $45K and it would be spot on.

2004 BMW 330Ci SPORT E46 MY04.5 Private Cars For Sale in VIC - carsales.com.au