More info:

What are you coming from and what did you like/dislike about that?

Your mix has 2 FWD, 1 AWD and 1 RWD car, which of these drivetrain layouts tickles you the most?

You also have 3 forced induction and 1 NA car, again, will this influence your decision? If tuning for gains is a consideration the NA will offer less - but then that's not what the MX-5 is about - its about being lightweight and achieveing a raw balance in its drive.

Do you value the interior as much as the exterior? Golf is classier.

Is warranty important - Mitsubishi warrants their cars well for performance vehicles.

Is number of seats or space a consideration? MX-5 falls down in comparison here.

Give us a hand here and we'll give one back.