Quote Originally Posted by SilvrFoxX View Post
The RS, that is sort of left field, you are basically getting a detuned GTI that is heavier..
The old RS ran the Mk5 engine so had the 147kW, the new RS is updated and runs the same 162kW engine. Obviously the weight as you suggest dulls things a fraction, but for space and value for money it's a no brainer.

If the badge really matters then yeah the S3 wins, while in the middle sit the two VWs.

Just depends on budget - a good quality Mk6 GTI should be had for no more than $30k but preferably less, and a good R should be had under $40k. I think some people are paying over the top privately or they're not selling at the advertised prices - either way as an informed buyer bargain down.